Prof Ruth Morgan
Professor of Crime and Forensic Science, UCL
Director, UCL Centre for the Forensic Sciences
Co-Director of the UCL Artista Institute
Published on October 15th, 2026
Introduction
It is broadly acknowledged that tackling today’s complex societal challenges requires interdisciplinary solutions that integrate knowledge and experience across diverse disciplines, fields, sectors and borders. As a result, forging and deploying interdisciplinary knowledge is often discussed and even promoted, yet despite its widely accepted value it is often very difficult to achieve. Interdisciplinarity demands coordination among people, organisations and disciplines that see the world differently, hold different priorities, and operate under different constraints. Establishing what the challenge is, let alone what successfully addressing it could look like, can be contentious. Navigating multiple and often contrasting (or even mutually contradictory) perspectives, and engaging with complex, dynamic interconnected systems is just part of what makes forging and deploying interdisciplinary knowledge so challenging. Yet it is critical for tackling complex challenges; challenges that are persistent, often seemingly intractable, and where traditional disciplinary approaches have not been able to resolve them, or even make progress at the pace and scale needed.
Two types of challenge
When we consider the complex challenges confronting us, it is possible to identify two types of challenge. The first is a class of challenge where single or traditionally multidisciplinary specialisms are addressing core issues, going deeper, developing new knowledge. This approach makes it possible to find new insights that can contribute to effectively navigating the challenge with many examples from domains such as public health and engineering of finding new knowledge that unlocks the challenge in question.
The second is a class of challenge (often termed WICKED challenges) where making progress and finding solutions is less about needing new knowledge, and more about bringing the wealth of specialist knowledge that exists across the disciplines in a way that creates synthesised knowledge that can lead to solutions. It is often when faced with this second type of challenge that we reach for interdisciplinarity, and where we seek answers at the intersection of different disciplines. Yet working at intersections is deeply challenging, even when there is a consensus that it is an effective approach for exploring the root issues and finding systemic and sustainable solutions.
It has been argued[1] that for this second class of challenge we need to bring different forms of (disciplinary) knowledge together, but we also need to enable the synthesis or cross pollination of that knowledge; cross pollination between disciplines as well as cross pollination between the knowledge that sits within different sectors, such as academia, industry and government. To do that we need to explore the language of proverbial pollination, the language that makes it possible to juxtapose different disciplinary knowledge and insights to find the resonances and the tensions, and to find ways to integrate that insight. Pollination in this sense moves us from simply cross pollinating, and to transforming gathered insight into new integrated knowledge (or to really go after the pollen analogy, make honey).
A common approach to achieving cross pollination is to seek the resonances, the common ground, between different disciplines. What is emerging from research is that to really foster cross pollination and achieve transformative interdisciplinary solutions, it is necessary to move beyond the resonances, and actively seek out the contradictions[2]. At the points of contradiction, it becomes possible to create new language or hybridised language that incorporates deep disciplinarity and makes it possible to expose the roots of challenges and pose new questions. It is often those questions that can create the path to genuinely interdisciplinary solutions that address the challenge systemically.
Why does this work?
Identifying contradictions reveals incompatibilities, blind spots, misunderstandings and language mismatch as well as exposing translation issues across complex ecosystems of knowledge. Contradictions also reveal challenges that may be at the root of a complex system which may not be the challenges that are becoming manifested more visibly. Leaning into those contradictions creates challenge and disruption in our current thinking and status quo approaches. It also drives the search for new language to articulate issues and critically enables us to derive different questions. So, if we are seeking interdisciplinary approaches and solutions, we need to create opportunities for contradictions and new questions in scientific culture within our science institutions.
Disciplinary dialogues
There are many ways to identify and explore important contradictions. However, three key factors tend to foster cultures of dialogue that create the conditions to explore contradictions:
Spaces
For this kind of interaction to take place, we need deep tangible dialogue across disciplines that incorporates counterpoint, debate and negotiation. That dialogue needs to be ongoing and not just at the edges of disciplines. This kind of dialogue is also needed at the heart of how each discipline formulates the questions it is addressing and that can only happen in a context where it is possible to overcome traditional institutional and disciplinary siloes.
Culture of challenge
There is no doubt that interdisciplinarity requires collaboration. At the same time, the common ground is only half of the equation. We need a culture that enables both collaboration and challenge, and not only a culture that fosters genuine debate and willingness to find the contradictions and the tensions, but a culture that makes it possible to explore and seek out language to do that constructively, thoughtfully and generously.
Different forms of expertise
To achieve these spaces and build this kind of culture we need to recognise and value different forms of expertise. We need to recognise and support the deep disciplinary specialists, and also the talented communicators who can not only foster cross-disciplinary translation but also through the fluency they develop, connect seemingly disparate dots, craft new kinds of questions, and re-imagine interdisciplinary challenges to derive transformative solutions. These are the skills that make it possible to see across scale from, for example, considering synergistically the cell structures within a tree, the tree itself, the forest made up of each tree, and the broader ecosystem of the forest at the local, regional and global scale. These are the skills that make it possible to navigate an ecosystem that includes not just science, but engineering, humanities and the arts, to see problems and solutions as they exist in society, on both the human and systemic levels. These are the skills needed to craft new interdisciplinary languages that make it possible to ask different questions and unlock interdisciplinary approaches wrought from deep disciplinarity to address today’s complex, dynamic and rapidly-changing challenges. It is time that within our institutions we increasingly recognise the value of the translators, the storytellers, and the mediators for the critical role they will play in enabling interdisciplinary approaches that tackle societal challenges and ensure science that serves society locally and globally.
This is of course easy to say and yet far harder to do. There are institutions that are already seeking to create spaces for deliberate disciplinary dialogue across knowledge sectors such as the McGill Sustainability Park, the ASU Global Futures Laboratory, and the Centre for Unusual Collaborations formed from an alliance of Eindhoven University of Technology, Wageningen University and Research, Utrecht University and University Medical Centre Utrecht. Spaces like these are important, and at the same time there is still work to do to embed more broadly new ways of thinking about how we collaborate, how we generate questions, and how we articulate challenges. Achieving this will take a willingness to re-think how we bring deep disciplinary and sector knowledge together, and how we integrate science with society in a dynamic world that is experiencing profound and rapid transformation. It will also require agility and flexibility in our approaches as the transformations we are witnessing in society today continue to revolutionise our way of life and inevitably bring more complex challenges along the way.
References
Morgan, R. (2026) [Title of paper TBC]. Royal Society Open Science (forthcoming).
Morgan, R. and Biriotti, M. (2025) Designing AI for humanity: Why disciplines must clash now. World Economic Forum. https://www.weforum.org/stories/emerging-technologies/designing-ai-for-humanity-why-disciplines-must-clash/
Copyright: © 2026 [author(s)]. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) or licensor are credited and that the original publication in Frontiers Policy Labs is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.

